Was that you, Holy Mary full of grace
Was that you? Tonight you're showing off your pretty face
Was that you, giving me the evil eye
Was that you with another guy

Was that you? You called me up to break our date
Was that you? You told me you were working late
Was that you? I think you need another alibi
Was that you with another guy

Well, I knew it was you, 'cause your dress was red
And you wore your sunglasses on your head
I would follow the trail of broken hearts
And know you're around here somewhere
Don't you care?
Was that you?

Was that you? Now you're acting like there's nothing wrong
Was that you, the leading lady in my sad song
Was that you? I'll bet you'd really love to see me cry
Was that you with another guy
Was that you with another guy

Was that you?
You know, it'd have to be you
Out it in the parking lot
You
You're always making time
You
You're with another guy
You